In Episode 39 of QuickBooks Mastery for Small Business Success, Erica Northrup and Lee Davis discuss an area of QuickBooks that can easily become confusing for business owners: payroll.
Payroll may look like one large expense when money leaves your bank account, but that’s not actually how payroll works from an accounting perspective.
Payroll is not one transaction.
It involves multiple expenses, liabilities, and accounts—and understanding the difference is essential if you want your financial statements to accurately reflect what your business is spending.
Listen to Episode 39!
Payroll Is Not Just Payroll Expense
One of the biggest misconceptions about payroll is that the entire amount that leaves your bank account should be categorized as a payroll expense.
That’s not correct.
Some of the money associated with payroll represents actual expenses, while other amounts are liabilities that the business is responsible for paying to government agencies, employees, or retirement plans.
If you want to understand how much your business is actually spending on payroll, you need to look at the breakdown.
Payroll Involves Multiple Accounts
Depending on your business and payroll setup, payroll can involve several different accounts.
These may include:
- Wage expense
- Payroll tax expense
- Federal payroll liabilities
- State payroll liabilities
- State and federal unemployment liabilities
- Medicare liabilities
- Social Security liabilities
- Retirement contributions
Each of these accounts has a different purpose.
That’s why simply looking at the amount that came out of your bank account doesn’t necessarily tell you how much payroll actually cost your business.
Why Do Payroll Liabilities Matter?
Payroll liabilities represent money that your business has collected or owes but has not yet paid to the appropriate party.
For example, payroll may include amounts withheld from an employee’s paycheck that need to be sent to the government.
Those amounts aren’t additional business expenses.
They are liabilities.
Eventually, when those liabilities are paid, the liability account should be reduced.
This distinction is important because incorrectly categorizing payroll can make your Profit & Loss and Balance Sheet inaccurate.
Two Payroll Reports That Can Help
QuickBooks provides payroll reports that can help business owners understand what is happening with payroll.
Payroll Register
The Payroll Register provides information about employee wages, including gross wages.
It can help you verify what employees were paid.
Payroll Summary
The Payroll Summary provides a broader breakdown of payroll information and can help you understand the different payroll expenses and liabilities involved.
These reports give you more information than simply looking at the amount that left your bank account.
A Common Problem: Too Much Payroll Expense
One of the problems Lee and Erica see is businesses overstating their payroll expense while understating their payroll liabilities.
This can happen when the entire payroll transaction is recorded as an expense.
The result is a financial statement that doesn’t accurately reflect what’s happening in the business.
If you suspect this is happening in your QuickBooks file, go back to your payroll records and compare them with the way the transactions are being recorded.
The goal is to make sure the payroll information is flowing into the correct accounts.
Warning Signs Your Payroll Needs Attention
There are several red flags that can indicate a payroll accounting problem.
1. The Entire Payroll Is Classified as an Expense
If every dollar associated with payroll is being recorded as an expense, it’s worth taking a closer look.
Some portions of payroll may belong in liability accounts rather than expense accounts.
2. Payroll Liabilities Keep Growing
If your payroll liability accounts continue to grow month after month, you need to find out why.
Liabilities should generally be paid down as the associated obligations are remitted.
A growing balance that no one can explain is a warning sign.
3. Old Payroll Liabilities Can’t Be Explained
Look at the age of your payroll liabilities.
If you have old balances sitting in your accounts and nobody knows what they represent, it’s time to investigate.
Don’t simply ignore them because the numbers are on the Balance Sheet.
4. Multiple Wage Accounts Serve the Same Purpose
Another warning sign is having multiple wage accounts that essentially represent the same thing.
Too many duplicate or unnecessary accounts can make your financial statements confusing and make it harder to understand your true payroll costs.
5. Retirement Payments Don’t Reduce the Retirement Liability
If your business makes retirement plan contributions but the corresponding retirement liability isn’t being reduced, something may not be recorded correctly.
The liability should reflect what the business actually owes.
When the payment is made, the liability should be properly accounted for.
6. Payroll Reconciles to the Bank—but the Financial Statements Don’t Make Sense
This is an especially important warning sign.
You might reconcile your bank account and see that everything appears to match.
But that doesn’t necessarily mean your payroll accounting is correct.
Your financial statements also need to make sense.
A transaction can match the bank and still be categorized incorrectly.
Payroll Affects Both Major Financial Statements
Payroll accounting affects both the Profit & Loss Statement and the Balance Sheet.
The Profit & Loss needs to accurately show the expenses associated with payroll.
The Balance Sheet needs to accurately show outstanding payroll liabilities.
If either side is wrong, your overall financial picture can be misleading.
That’s why business owners shouldn’t stop at asking:
“Did the payroll clear the bank?”
A better question is:
“Was the payroll recorded correctly?”
How Do You Know What Your Payroll Is Really Costing?
If you want to understand your true payroll costs, don’t simply look at the bank account.
Review your payroll reports.
Look at:
- Gross wages
- Employer payroll taxes
- Employee withholdings
- Payroll liabilities
- Retirement contributions
- Other payroll-related costs
Then compare those figures to what’s appearing in your financial statements.
This gives you a much clearer picture of what your employees actually cost the business.
Payroll Should Be Reviewed Regularly
Payroll is one of the largest expenses for many businesses.
That makes it especially important to review it regularly.
Don’t wait until tax time to discover that your payroll liabilities have been sitting on your Balance Sheet for months or that your Profit & Loss doesn’t accurately reflect your payroll costs.
A regular review can help you catch problems while they’re still relatively easy to correct.
Final Thoughts
Payroll can be complicated because it involves much more than wages.
There are expenses, liabilities, taxes, withholdings, retirement contributions, and payments that all need to be recorded correctly.
The key takeaway from Episode 39 is simple:
Payroll is not one transaction.
If your entire payroll is being treated as an expense, if liabilities are growing without explanation, or if your payroll numbers don’t make sense on your financial statements, it’s time to take a closer look.
Use your Payroll Register and Payroll Summary to understand the details. Reconcile your accounts, review your liabilities, and make sure the information on your Profit & Loss and Balance Sheet tells the right story.
And if you aren’t sure what you’re looking at, don’t guess. Getting help from someone who understands both payroll and QuickBooks can save you from much bigger cleanup problems later.
Accurate payroll accounting isn’t just about getting the numbers into QuickBooks. It’s about knowing what those numbers mean—and making sure they accurately represent your business.
If you liked the podcast, you will like our training course. Click on the link below to join our upcoming course.